Filed under: China, Federal Natl Mtge (FNM), Housing
It’s not clear how big the bailout of Fannie Mae (NYSE: FNM) and Freddie Mac (NYSE: FRE) will be but it is becoming clearer who it is for. Yesterday, I appeared on CNBC’s Power Lunch to discuss the winners and losers from the collapse in their common and preferred equity. But today, Bloomberg News reports that one of the biggest beneficiaries of the bailout will be the government of China.
In addition to buying most of our consumer goods from China, our government could use as much as $800 billion of our tax dollars to assure that China and other holders of Fannie and Freddie assets don’t suffer any losses. Bloomberg interviews Yu Yongding, a former adviser to China’s central bank who stated, “If the U.S. government allows Fannie and Freddie to fail and international investors are not compensated adequately, the consequences will be catastrophic. If it isn’t the end of the world, it is the end of the current international financial system.”
That sounds like a pretty strong statement to me. I’m not sure why Yu made it or what it means. So I will throw in a mixture of fact and fiction to offer my interpretation. Bloomberg reports that China holds $376 billion worth of “long-term U.S. bureau debt [which] is mostly in Fannie and Freddie assets.” CLSA estimates that the six biggest Chinese banks hold $30 billion worth of such paper, according to Bloomberg. Those are the facts, now comes the fiction part.
If Fannie and Freddie fail, that means common shareholders are wiped out and preferred shareholders take a huge haircut. But what impact does such a failure have on the holders of mortgage-backed securities that Fannie and Freddie issued to countries like China? It seems to me that as long as the holders of the underlying mortgages keep paying and Fannie and Freddie — using our $800 billion — take up the slack for mortgage holders who default, then China and the other holders don’t get injured.
Here’s why our government has no problem using our money to bailout these holders and is happy to let common and preferred shareholders take their losses. Because if China loses money on its Fannie and Freddie holdings, it may stop buying our government debt and put its burgeoning cash reserves into other currencies — such as Euros — which have appreciated 62% relative to the dollar since January 2001. That would cause the dollar to plummet and would force the U.S. to raise the interest rates it pays on its debt.
And those higher interest rates would make the current credit crunch look like a day at the beach. With apologies to Ernest Hemingway, ask not for whom the bailout bell tolls, it tolls for Yu.
Peter Cohan is President of Peter S. Cohan & Associates. He also teaches management at Babson College and edits The Cohan Letter. He has no financial interest in the securities mentioned.
Share This
Share This